Thats just words that most people, about 9095%, blow off and roll. The main difference between aa and a real cult is that aa excludes no one, and nonadherence to dogma carries no punishment other than disapproval to various degrees from varying members of the community. It feels like i am wasting time sitting in a room for 1 and a half hours. By charles bufe with an introduction by stanton peele tucson, arizona. An examination of the cult aspects of alcoholics anonymous. Cult or cure with a description of a standard aa meetingdominated by a few people who tell their same, selfserving stories for the umpteenth time, the proceedings unfocussed and unhelpful, the. We left the title alcoholics anonymous in the copy that went to the printer. Cult speak, groupthink, suppression of dissent, and enforced conformity in thinking. If youre familiar with the world of addiction recovery, then youre no doubt acquainted with alcoholics anonymousor aa as it is more commonly known. The fourth edition includes twentyfour new stories that provide contemporary sharing for newcomers seeking recovery from alcoholism in a. When you consider these facts, all belief systems that are sought after have the ability to become cults and can be viewed as cults by certain people, the contention of alcoholics anonymous is not a cult is utterly false. T he alcoholics anonymous big book is not just the most influential self help book ever published.
Bufe concluded that aa is not a cult, though it does have dangerous cult like tendencies. Narcotics anonymous has turned into a cult, the opposite they believe your marginalize. The very first sentence in chapter 5 of the big book of alcoholics anonymous, describes it the best. Bufe refrains from expounding his own pet theory of addiction and wisely fills the pages instead with a. Cain a useful idea has turned into a religious movementand a hindrance to research, psychiatry, and to many alcoholics who need a different kind of help. Silkworths belladonna cure, a treatment regimen which included morphine and other psychoactive drugs in addition to belladonna which in large doses is a powerful hallucinogen. But there are also so many active factors that affect addiction and recovery, such as relapse, level of function, and resulting illnesses. All aa members know the origins of the program from the oxford group. Alcoholics anonymous as a cult scorecard, answers 41 to 50. It questions the methods used by alcoholics anonymous such as the steps, and shows how aa grew from a fundamentalist religious organisation called the oxford group. I started to feel this way when last year i moved in with a roommate who insisted i needed aa, despite the fact that i literally have less then 1 drink a month. Alcoholics anonymous, book by anonymous anonymous paperback. It quotes many studies to back up its claims that aa is useless at healing addiction, and that it is a damaging cult that is erroding away society.
The original working manuscript is the missing link between bill wilsons first draft of alcoholics anonymous and the first edition. Cultspeak, groupthink, suppression of dissent, and enforced conformity in thinking. Nicknamed the big book by the early aa members for its thick paper and wide margins, the books history began in 1934 when bill wilson, an alcoholic stockbroker who had found sobriety. If you have been abused by aa or its sister programs, then please read this book, it will help to deprogram you back into the real world. The distinction from regular cults is that it has no apparent head.
To discuss the mechanism of action, the efficacy and the safety of alcoholics anonymous aa in the treatment of alcoholism. Alcoholics anonymous cult aa resembles a religious cult as a group which does not tolerate any kind of individuality or freedom of thought, aa exhibits characteristics of religious affiliations which have been called cults because of the emotional and cognitive harm they do to their members. An alternative title, the way out, had strong support from members, but a check of the library of congress showed twelve books with that title. The result of this clandestine effort was a decisive study published in california sociologist, alcoholics anonymous. Charlie sheen turns on the cult the clean slate addiction site. On that day he was readmitted to towns hospital, sedated, and subjected to dr. Orange to go back and forth between the questions and the answers for alcoholics anonymous, click on the numbers of the questions and answers. Glancing through harvards community narratives publication, youll find personal aa stories that highlight the notion that, if you disagree with the steps, it somehow means you are in denial and destined to fail. Alcoholics anonymous destroys selfesteem and selfsufficiency. Criticism of aa or alcoholics anonymous is nothing new. Rarely have we seen a person fail, who has thoroughly followed our path.
I am just coming upto 24 years clean and i no longer need na in my life. Alcoholics anonymous alcoholics anonymous bauman rare books. Dec 09, 2014 posted by 12 step cult religion exposed on december 9, 2014 in 12 step truth dangerous cult, aa murder, fanatical religious shitbags, truth regarding alcoholics anonymous finally. Its a cult in the sense that it manipulates you into believing you can. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. When i think of cults, i picture the manson family. Alcoholics anonymous great britain and english speaking continental europe. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading alcoholics anonymous. Cult or cure on december 11,1934, wilsons drinking came to a screeching halt.
Founded in 1997, has become a leading book price comparison site. Now, i am a christian, but i read this article about alcoholics anonymous and why some atheists think it is a cult, and i have to say i agree. Give it a good read and then head toward one of many secular self help books that. She kept telling me i needed spiritual healing and i thought no, i dont, i have all the. In the forward to the first edition of the aa big book, they state that there are more than 100 men and women who have recovered from alcoholism. Bufe concluded that aa is not a cult, though it does have dangerous cultlike tendencies. Aa religion continues to impede progress for alcoholism. And if youve had more than two or three aarelated conversations, its highly likely that someone compared aa to a cult in at least one of those discussions.
The dirty, dangerous, cult, is on bayview e in fort lauderdale, fl, spreading a false rumor, a narrative, that a cop is aa, and that some one crippled them, its fake,its false, no truth to it at all, they created there on trouble, they created their own troubles,they are disillusioned, corrupt, dishonest, and a good number of them, take pills, pills, pills and sell them, its a bad. I think this even popped up earlier in links that people were posting in online discussions i was involved with. The 164 and more book, ebook, and web site are all concordances which display passages from the big book alcoholics anonymous, the twelve steps and twelve traditions, and the a. See all of the alcoholics anonymous book lots now available on one page. Select from the options below for more information. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. I had to attend as part of some court action against me. In inside perspective on aa members and how they treat people who do not agree with their methods of recovering from alcoholism. I recently read the sober truth which is an excellent book by lance dodes. With an active marketplace of over 175 million items, use the alibris advanced search page to find any item you are looking for through the advanced search, you can find items by searching specific terms such as title, artist, song title, genre, etc or you can narrow. The published works on effective treatments for alcoho. Denigration of competing sects, cults, religions, personal attacks on critics. I started to feel this way when last year i moved in with a roommate who insisted i needed aa, despite the fact that i literally have less then 1 drink. Freedom of mindaa is aaalcoholics anonymous a cult.
Essentially, alexander and rollins measured aa against criteria developed by robert j. Free books and book excerpts including the complete the real aa and alcoholics anonymous. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. He gives the reader an in depth history of the foundations of alcholics anonymous which are clearly religious in nature. Jul 06, 2009 is alcoholics anonymousnarcotics anonymous a cult. In the us, the antiaa lobby has been further fuelled by the recent publication of two books. Aa takes advantage of vulnerable people for the purpose of unsolicited religious indonctrination. Alcoholics anonymous quotes by charles bufe goodreads. General service conferenceapproved literature reflects the group conscience of the fellowship of a. Article in australian and new zealand journal of psychiatry 396. Find all the books, read about the author, and more.
All things aa related big books, step working guides, meditations, medallions, posters and more. This well researched, painstakingly documented book provides detailed information on the rightwing evangelical organization oxford group movement that gave birth. Jul 05, 2017 the success rates of alcoholics anonymous are hard to come by, primarily because the program is supposed to be anonymous hence the title. Charlie sheen turns on the cult and feels the wrath of. There are many voices crying out for a dramatic change in the way evangelicals have traditionally viewed catholicism. The story of how many thousands of men and women have recovered from alcoholism by anonymous, alcoholics and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at. Its one of the 20th centurys most significant books and early copies are treasured by numerous collectors.
A guide to collecting alcoholics anonymous big book passion for books. Its actually a christian missionary project that uses alcoholism as an incurable disease bullshit to bind you in vassalage to your deity and to encourage certain christian behavior. In the beginning they created alcoholics anonymous. Do you have a story as to why you left a 12 step program such as alcoholics anonymous, narcotics anonymous, alanon, alateen, cocaine anonymous, sexaholics anonymous, over eaters anonymous, neurotics anonymous, gamblers anonymous, adult children of alcoholics, heroin anonymous, crystal meth anonymous, clutterers anonymous, naranon, debtors anonymous, sex and love anonymous, workaholics anonymous. Unquestionable dogma, sacred science, and infallible ideology. Cure in big book alcoholics anonymous, 12 steps and 12. Another cult comparison is aas tendency to discourage personal identity and the need to challenge traditional 12step thinking. The 12 step program has helped countless people get and stay clean and sober. Aug 06, 2015 in inside perspective on aa members and how they treat people who do not agree with their methods of recovering from alcoholism. A guide to collecting alcoholics anonymous big book. Of course, i ve known about your blog and your writing for ages. For any christian involved in the aa program, its occultic origins should be of very grave concern. In alcoholics anonymous, cult or cure, bufe gives us an intelligible analysis of the largest recovery group in the united states and perhaps the world.
The evangelical church is at a crucial point in its history. The antiaa book that saved my butt after reading ken ragges the real aa behind the myth of 12 step recovery, i simply could not go back to meetings. Neither ragge nor bufe seems to have been aware of a very pertinent article written in 1984 by two astute californians, francesca alexander and michele rollins. Posted by 12 step cult religion exposed on december 9, 2014 in 12 step truth dangerous cult, aa murder, fanatical religious shitbags, truth regarding alcoholics anonymous finally. The above examples are just a few quotes from the literature used in the program of alcoholics anonymous of which the books alcoholics anonymous, twelve steps and twelve traditions are the most commonly used.
Cain a useful idea has turned into a religious movementand a hindrance to research, psychiatry, and to many alcoholics who. Bufe the heretics handbook of quotations, see sharp pr. Aa is a religious cult dressed up to look like a treatment for alcoholism. This book should be the first for anyone who is skeptical of aa methods. Nov 17, 2014 alcoholics anonymous destroys self esteem. Alcoholics anonymous aa as it is generally known was started in the 1930s as a spinoff from the oxford group, a religious movement whose ideas were sometimes alleged to help chronic drinkers. Sorting and rendering passages in the proprietary format of the 164 and more concordance does not in any way imply affiliation with or endorsement by either alcoholics. Daily reflections, a compilation of spiritual reflections contributed by members. Lifton, whose 1961 work, thought reform and the psychology of totalism, is a classic work on thought reform or. Alcoholics anonymous also known as the big book in recovery circles sets forth cornerstone concepts of recovery from alcoholism and tells the stories of men and women who have overcome the disease. The published works on effective treatments for alcoholism is brie. But there are other people who picture alcoholics anonymous. Cure in big book alcoholics anonymous, 12 steps and 12 traditions. See sharp press, 1998 introduction to charles bufes aa.
793 971 299 550 1038 201 1268 778 317 672 1409 1379 919 1144 1243 242 409 994 1036 652 159 1292 160 87 261 1038 366 1153 336 68 1043 313 346 242 1053